CMI vs. LSM, MTM and MMM: Active and Passive Magnetometry Compared

Current Magnetometry Inspection (CMI) and large stand-off magnetometry (LSM) both inspect buried pipelines from above ground with magnetometers. LSM is also known as the magnetic tomography method (MTM) or metal magnetic memory (MMM). The two approaches measure different things. LSM, MTM and MMM are passive and look for mechanical stress in the pipe wall. CMI is active: it measures the magnetic field of an inspection current and shows where the coating is damaged and whether the steel underneath is corroding.

CMI vs. LSM at a Glance

LSM, MTM, MMM CMI
Principle Passive. Measures the magnetic field of the pipe itself, which changes with mechanical stress Active. Measures the magnetic field of an inspection current fed into the pipeline
Connection to the pipeline None Existing cathodic protection test posts
Main result Zones of elevated mechanical stress Every coating defect and a corrosion rate for each one
Geometry Pipeline route and depth of cover 2D and 3D pipeline scan with depth of cover, bending strain and pipe movement
Coating and cathodic protection Covered by separate surveys such as CIPS and DCVG Coating defects and corrosion rate come from the same survey
Typical use Screening for geohazards and stress-related threats Deciding which coating defects need action
Pipeline in service Yes Yes

LSM, MTM, MMM and SCT: Different Names, One Principle

Passive above-ground magnetometry is offered under several names. They differ by provider and region.

Name Stands for Background
LSM Large stand-off magnetometry The general term in industry and research papers
MTM Magnetic tomography method Developed by Transkor-K and described in several patents. A validation programme by NYSEARCH describes it as passive: no electric signal and no magnetic excitation is applied to the pipe
MMM Metal magnetic memory A non-destructive testing technique with its own standard, ISO 24497. Applied from above ground it is also called non-contact magnetometric diagnostics (NMD)
SCT Stress concentration tomography A screening tool in the same category

The principle is the same in each case. The sensors record the magnetic field that the steel pipe has in the earth's field, and the evaluation looks for anomalies caused by mechanical stress. In this article, LSM stands for the whole group.

How LSM Works

Steel is ferromagnetic. In the earth's magnetic field, a buried steel pipe carries a magnetic field of its own. Mechanical stress changes the magnetisation of the steel. This is called inverse magnetostriction, or the Villari effect.

An LSM survey records the magnetic field above the pipeline with an array of magnetometers, carried by a technician or a drone. Software searches the data for anomalies and translates them into zones of elevated stress. Sources of such stress include ground and slope movement, bending, dents, wrinkles and other defects in the pipe wall.

LSM applies no signal and needs no connection to the pipeline. Published work describes it as a screening technology. A paper at the ASME International Pipeline Conference 2020 reports the strongest signals for large-scale stress caused by geohazards, and names consistency for small, localised anomalies as the main open challenge at that time.

Technical drawing of passive magnetometry (LSM, MTM, MMM): a magnetometer array above ground records a local anomaly in the magnetic field of a buried steel pipe caused by mechanical stress. No signal is applied.PASSIVE MAGNETOMETRY: LSM, MTM, MMMGROUND LEVELEarth's magnetic fieldStress zone: bending, dent,ground movement or defectLocal anomaly in themagnetic field of the pipeMagnetometer arrayNo signal is appliedSteel pipe, magnetised in the earth's field

Passive magnetometry (LSM, MTM, MMM): the sensors record the magnetic field of the pipe itself. No signal is applied. The result is a list of locations with elevated mechanical stress.

How CMI Works

EMPIT developed Current Magnetometry Inspection (CMI) for unpiggable pipelines. An inspection current is fed into the pipeline through existing cathodic protection test posts. A technician walks the line with the Current Mapper, which measures the magnetic field of that current above the buried pipe. Water crossings are surveyed by boat, hard-to-reach terrain by drone.

Because the signal is applied, it is known. Where the coating is damaged, part of the current leaves the pipe and enters the soil. CMI detects this current loss and locates the defect. A multi-frequency analysis then shows whether the steel is protected by a surface layer or is actively corroding.

Technical drawing of Current Magnetometry Inspection (CMI): a signal generator feeds an inspection current into the buried pipe at a cathodic protection test post, a sensor array above ground measures the magnetic field of that current, and current leaving the pipe marks a coating defect.ACTIVE MAGNETOMETRY: CMIGROUND LEVELIIInspection currentflows along the pipeSignal generatorMULTI-FREQUENCYCP test postCurrent is fedinto the pipeCurrent leaves the pipeat a coating defectCurrent Mapper: sensor arraymeasures the field of the currentMagnetic field of theinspection current

Active magnetometry (CMI): an inspection current is fed into the pipe and its magnetic field is measured above ground. Where current leaves the pipe, the coating is damaged.

EMPIT technician walking a pipeline right of way with the Current Mapper during a CMI survey

CMI survey on land. The Current Mapper measures the magnetic field of the inspection current above the buried pipe.

CMI result for an actively corroding coating defect
CMI result for a passivated coating defect

CMI separates actively corroding coating defects from passivated ones.

What Each Method Tells You

LSM
Where is the pipe under stress?
A list of locations with elevated mechanical stress, plus the route and depth of cover of the line. Operators use it to prioritise sections for a closer look.
CMI
Which coating defects are corroding?
Every coating defect located by GPS, a corrosion rate in µm per year for each one, and a 2D and 3D scan of the pipeline with depth of cover.

The two methods answer different questions. External corrosion on a coated, cathodically protected pipeline is an electrochemical process at a coating defect. CMI measures the current at that defect. LSM measures stress, not current, so coating condition and cathodic protection are covered by separate surveys such as CIPS and DCVG.

When to Use Which

  • External corrosion and coating condition: CMI. You see which defects are corroding and which are not, so excavations go where they are needed. See corrosion detection and corrosion assessment.
  • Ground movement, landslides and subsidence: both methods contribute. LSM infers stress from the magnetisation of the steel. CMI measures the position of the pipe in 3D and derives bending strain and pipe movement from it.
  • No electrical access to the pipeline: LSM needs no connection. CMI needs test posts or another contact point to feed in the current.
  • Route and depth of cover: both methods map the line.

Proven in the Field

In the DVGW NEMEK field study, 6,672 coating defects were assessed with CMI. Three of them were actively corroding. In a blind test with North America's largest energy company, nobody told the inspection team where the defects were. All thirteen were found from the surface, with no false calls. On another unpiggable line, CMI found 80% wall loss that potential surveys had missed.

EMPIT inspects more than 10,000 km of pipeline a year, with teams in Europe and the USA.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is CMI the same as LSM or MTM?

No. All of them are above-ground magnetometry methods, but LSM, MTM and MMM are passive and report mechanical stress. CMI is active and reports coating defects, their corrosion rate and the geometry of the pipeline.

Does either method require a shutdown?

No. Both surveys are carried out from above ground while the pipeline stays in service. Nothing enters the pipe.

Can CMI and LSM be combined with ECDA?

Above-ground surveys are the indirect inspection step of ECDA. Operators who work to ECDA use CMI as a complementary indirect inspection tool. See where CMI fits in the four ECDA steps.

Start with a Pilot Section

Send us the route of one section. We will tell you what a CMI survey can deliver there.

Sources

Back