Excavated coating defect on a 3LPE coated pipeline: removed coating piece with corrosion products and the disbonded area on the pipe

CMI vs. DCVG: The Benchmark Where DCVG Missed the Test Coupon

A DCVG survey is the usual way to locate coating defects on a buried pipeline. In a benchmark on a 36-inch gas pipeline of Transitgas AG in Switzerland, DCVG located two coating defects on a 1,433 m section. Current Magnetometry Inspection (CMI) confirmed both and located more than 20 in total, including a 1 cm² test coupon that DCVG did not detect.

The Benchmark at a Glance

PipelineGas transmission pipeline of Transitgas AG in Switzerland, built in 1973
Test sectionFrom the southern bank of the Rhine to the Wallbach station, about 1,433 m
Pipe36 inch (914.4 mm) diameter, 12.7 mm wall thickness
CoatingBituminous coating, about 5.5 mm thick
Cathodic protectionOn potential about -2 V (CSE), not shifted for the survey
ReferenceTest coupon with a steel surface of 1 cm², buried at a depth of about 80 cm
DCVG result2 coating defects located
CMI resultBoth DCVG defects confirmed, more than 20 coating defects located in total, test coupon located

Why Compare CMI with DCVG?

Direct Current Voltage Gradient (DCVG) is a coating survey. It uses the current of the cathodic protection system as its source and measures the voltage gradient in the soil above the pipeline with two electrodes. Where current enters the steel through a coating defect, a gradient appears. DCVG shows where the coating is damaged. It does not show whether the steel at the defect is corroding.

On pipelines with a high quality coating the defects are small, and small defects produce small voltage gradients. To make them visible, a DCVG survey is often run with an increased potential swing, which means a clearly more negative on potential. The defects found this way are then excavated and recoated. In practice only very few of these excavations turn out to be necessary. In most cases the cathodic protection was working and the steel showed no active corrosion [1].

CMI takes a different route. A signal generator feeds an alternating inspection current into the pipeline, and a detector with up to 70 sensors records the magnetic field of that current from above ground in all three directions. Where current leaves the pipe through a coating defect, the field changes. The on potential of the cathodic protection stays where it is.

How Was the Benchmark Set Up?

The test section belongs to a gas transmission pipeline of Transitgas AG that was built in 1973. It runs from the southern bank of the Rhine to the Wallbach station and is about 1,433 m long. The pipe has a diameter of 36 inches (914.4 mm) and a wall thickness of 12.7 mm. It is protected by a bituminous coating about 5.5 mm thick.

The on potential was about -2 V against a copper/copper sulphate electrode. It was not shifted further negative for the survey, to avoid any risk of AC corrosion or coating disbondment. For an objective check of both methods, a test coupon with a steel surface of 1 cm² was buried at a depth of about 80 cm. Both methods surveyed the same section. The DCVG data came from the cathodic protection contractor.

What Did DCVG and CMI Find?

DCVG located two coating defects, one near the start and one near the end of the section. CMI found a defect at both positions, so the two methods agree on these two.

CMI located more than 20 coating defects in total. One of them is the test coupon at about 800 m. Its position and its size were known, which makes it the reference of the benchmark. CMI located it. DCVG did not detect it under the given measurement conditions [1].

02550751000200400600800100012001400TEST COUPON, 1 CM²CMI INDICATIONDCVG INDICATIONDISTANCE ALONG THE SECTION [M]SIGNAL STRENGTH [%]
Coating defect indications along the test section, signal strength normalised to the highest value. The dashed line marks the test coupon. Redrawn from the data published in [1].

More indications do not mean more excavations. CMI assesses every coating defect it finds, so the operator digs where the steel is at risk.

This assessment is the core of EMPIT's Corrosion Detection service.

What Did the Excavation Show?

To check a CMI result that DCVG had not confirmed, one location was excavated on another pipeline in Switzerland, this one with a three-layer polyethylene (3LPE) coating. CMI had indicated two separate coating defects of about 0.1 cm² each.

Both were there. When the coating was removed, it turned out to be disbonded over an area of about 12 cm² around them. The steel showed minor metal loss and voluminous corrosion products. Very small coating defects, voluminous corrosion products, a large disbonded area and limited metal loss are the typical picture of AC corrosion [1, 2].

INDICATED BY CMI2 COATING DEFECTSABOUT 0.1 CM² EACHFOUND AT THE EXCAVATIONDISBONDED COATINGABOUT 12 CM²2 COATING DEFECTSABOUT 0.1 CM² EACHSCHEMATIC, AREAS DRAWN TO SCALE
The excavated location on the 3LPE coated pipeline: the two coating defects indicated by CMI, and the disbonded coating that appeared when the coating was removed. Schematic based on [1].

The finding matters for the way surveys are run. More negative on potentials can accelerate AC corrosion [2]. A method that locates small coating defects without shifting the potential avoids this risk during the survey.

A Pipe Bend That Was Not in the Pipe Book

CMI records more than coating defects. From the same magnetic field data it calculates the position and depth of cover of the pipe in three dimensions, with a resolution of 1 cm along the line. At the excavated location CMI showed a pipe bend that should not have been there according to the pipe book. The excavation confirmed the bend.

Position data of this quality also show where a pipeline has moved. From the displacement, the bending strain on the pipe can be derived. This matters in particular when a pipeline is converted to hydrogen.

What Does the Benchmark Mean for Operators?

  • No potential shift: coating defects are located with the cathodic protection at its normal setting. The survey adds no risk of AC corrosion or coating disbondment.
  • Small defects are found: CMI located the 1 cm² test coupon and the two defects of about 0.1 cm² on the 3LPE coated pipeline.
  • Every defect is assessed: the number of indications is higher, but excavations go to the defects that are relevant for corrosion.
  • Position included: the same survey delivers the 3D position of the pipe, which is how the undocumented bend was found.

The comparison was published in the journal 3R, issue 01|2024 [1].

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between CMI and DCVG?

DCVG measures the voltage gradient in the soil with two electrodes and uses the cathodic protection current as its source. CMI feeds an alternating inspection current into the pipeline and measures its magnetic field from above ground. Both locate coating defects. CMI also assesses the corrosion activity at each defect and maps the position of the pipe.

Can a DCVG survey detect corrosion?

No. DCVG is a coating survey. It locates coating defects, but it does not show whether the steel at a defect is corroding.

Why did DCVG not detect the test coupon?

Small coating defects produce small voltage gradients in the soil. In the benchmark the on potential was not shifted further negative, and under these conditions DCVG did not detect the 1 cm² coupon. CMI located it.

Does the cathodic protection have to be changed for a CMI survey?

No. CMI works with its own inspection current. The on potential stays at its normal setting and the pipeline stays in service.

Start with a Pilot Section

Send us the length, diameter and location of your line. We tell you whether CMI fits and what a pilot section would look like.

Sources

  1. M. Glinka, M. Büchler, D. Luisier, F. Linder: Evaluation of the Corrosion Protection of Buried Pipelines: The Use of Current Magnetometry Inspection (CMI). 3R, Journal for Safe and Efficient Pipeline Systems, 01|2024.
  2. M. Büchler: Alternating current corrosion of cathodically protected pipelines: Discussion of the involved processes and their consequences on the critical interference values. Materials and Corrosion 63, 1181 (2012).
  3. AMPP (NACE) TM0109: Aboveground Survey Techniques for the Evaluation of Underground Pipeline Coating Condition.

Read more

02. August 2023

DCVG vs. CIPS vs. ACVG: What Each Survey Finds and What It Cannot Tell You

Read more

21. February 2026

DVGW Research Confirms: CMI Detects Pipeline Corrosion Where Conventional Methods Fail

Read more

Back