Complex Facility CMI DCVG

DCVG vs. CIPS vs. ACVG: What Each Survey Finds and What It Cannot Tell You

CIPS, DCVG and ACVG are the standard above-ground surveys for buried, coated pipelines. CIPS shows how well cathodic protection is working along the route. DCVG and ACVG locate coating defects. None of the three shows whether the steel at a coating defect is actually corroding. This comparison explains what each survey measures, where it stops, and how Current Magnetometry Inspection (CMI) answers the open question.

DCVG, CIPS and ACVG at a Glance

SurveyWhat it measuresWhat it tells youCorrosion at the defect?
CIPS (close interval potential survey, also CIS)Pipe-to-soil potential at close intervals along the route, usually with the CP current switched on and offThe level of cathodic protection along the pipelineNo
DCVG (direct current voltage gradient)The DC voltage gradient in the soil between two reference electrodes while the CP current is interruptedWhere coating defects are and how severe they are relative to each other (%IR)No
ACVG (alternating current voltage gradient)The AC voltage gradient in the soil created by an AC signal applied to the pipelineWhere coating defects are, with a signal strength in dBµVNo
CMI (Current Magnetometry Inspection)The magnetic field of a multi-frequency inspection current, measured contact-free above the pipelineWhere coating defects are and whether each one is active or passivatedYes

What Does a CIPS Survey Show?

A close interval potential survey records the pipe-to-soil potential along the whole pipeline at short, regular intervals. The surveyor walks the route with a reference electrode and a trailing wire connected to a test post. With the cathodic protection current switched on and off in a synchronised rhythm, the survey delivers an on and an off potential at every step. The procedure is described in AMPP standard practice SP0207.

Best for

Checking whether cathodic protection reaches the required level everywhere along the route.

Where it stops

CIPS reports potentials. It is not built to pinpoint and size individual coating defects, and a potential does not show whether a given defect is corroding.

What Does a DCVG Survey Show?

Where the coating is damaged, protection current flows through the soil to the exposed steel and creates a voltage gradient at the surface. A DCVG survey measures this gradient with two reference electrodes placed about a metre apart, while the CP current is interrupted so the signal can be told apart from other DC sources. The size of the gradient relative to the total potential shift gives the %IR value, which ranks defects by severity. The test method is AMPP TM0109.

Best for

Locating coating defects precisely and ranking them against each other.

Where it stops

A large gradient shows that current is flowing to the defect. It does not show whether the steel behind it is losing metal. In ECDA, DCVG is therefore combined with a second survey, usually CIPS.

What Does an ACVG Survey Show?

ACVG works on the same idea with an alternating signal. A transmitter applies an AC signal to the pipeline, and the surveyor measures the AC voltage gradient in the soil with a probe frame. The reading is given in dBµV and points towards the defect. ACVG is covered by the same test method, AMPP TM0109.

Best for

Locating coating defects where an interrupted CP current is not available or not practical.

Where it stops

Like DCVG, ACVG finds the coating defect, not the corrosion. It gives no information on the level of cathodic protection.

What None of the Three Can Tell You

All three surveys answer questions about the coating and the cathodic protection. None of them answers the question an operator has to decide on: is this defect corroding? A coating defect does not mean the pipeline is corroding. The steel may be fully passivated and protected by cathodic protection.

The consequence shows up in the excavations. In one field study covering roughly 300 km of pipeline and 200 excavations, 43 % of the excavated locations showed no corrosion at all. The details are in our blind test report.

Where Surveys Get Difficult: Complex Facilities

Compressor stations, valve clusters, metering stations and tank farms concentrate many pipelines, grounding systems, metallic structures and electrical installations in a confined space. These electrically connected components distort the signals that potential and gradient surveys rely on. Stray currents, galvanic interference from adjacent structures and local CP systems create noise that masks genuine coating defects. The result is unreliable data, missed defects and unnecessary excavations.

How CMI Answers the Open Question

CMI takes a different approach. A controlled multi-frequency AC current (2 Hz to 2 kHz) is applied to the pipeline. Up to 70 tri-axial sensors capture the magnetic field of this current in all three spatial directions at 20,000 data points per second, without contact to the soil. At every coating defect, part of the inspection current leaks into the surrounding soil. By analysing how this loss varies across the frequencies, CMI determines the location of each defect and the electrochemical state of the steel behind it.

  • Passivated defects: a protective layer has formed and cathodic protection is effective. These defects only need monitoring.
  • Active corrosion: bare steel is in direct contact with the soil and the corrosion cell is active. These defects go on the excavation list.

CMI does not shift the on-potential of the pipeline. Cathodic protection stays fully in operation during the inspection. The classification was validated in the DVGW research project NEMEK (G 202329), which reported a method reliability of 99.96 % across 6,672 detected coating defects. In a direct benchmark against DCVG on a 36-inch pipeline of Transitgas AG in Switzerland, CMI identified significantly more defects, including a 1 cm² test coupon that DCVG did not detect. Read more about the service: Corrosion Detection.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between DCVG and CIPS?

CIPS measures the pipe-to-soil potential along the route and shows the level of cathodic protection. DCVG measures voltage gradients in the soil and shows where coating defects are and how severe they are relative to each other. The two are often run together.

What is the difference between DCVG and ACVG?

Both locate coating defects through voltage gradients in the soil. DCVG uses the interrupted DC current of the cathodic protection system and rates defects in %IR. ACVG uses an applied AC signal and reports the signal strength in dBµV.

Does a coating defect always mean corrosion?

No. A coating defect is a pathway for current, not proof of metal loss. The steel may be passivated and fully protected. In one field study with 200 excavations, 43 % of the excavated locations showed no corrosion.

Can you tell from above ground whether a coating defect is corroding?

Yes, with Current Magnetometry Inspection. CMI classifies each coating defect as active or passivated from the frequency behaviour of the inspection current, while the pipeline and its cathodic protection stay in operation.

Start with a Pilot Section

Send us the route of one section or the layout of one facility. We will tell you what a CMI survey can deliver there.

Sources

Read more

05. November 2026

CMI Found 80% Wall Loss on an Unpiggable Pipeline That Potential Surveys Missed

Read more

21. February 2026

DVGW Research Confirms: CMI Detects Pipeline Corrosion Where Conventional Methods Fail

Read more

Back